Irish Feminist Network
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission Statement
    • Our Work
    • The Coordinators
  • Publications
  • News & Events
  • Articles
  • Take Action
  • Contact Us
    • Irish Organisations

“Science: It’s a Girl Thing!” – A female scientist’s perspective

2/7/2012

10 Comments

 
Picture
There’s definitely a time and a place for a video released as an attempt by the EU Commission to get more girls into science. The time for “Science: It’s A Girl Thing” a 53-second cringe featuring overly-sexualised minors strutting around in safety goggles and minidresses , salivating over how bubbling flasks and chemical formulas always lead to neon make-up is never, and the place is nowhere. By Naomi Elster

As one blogger put it "The EU Commission may as well have put a lipstick on a string, and filmed 18 year old models doing a belly crawl after it from the nail parlour (or wherever they would normally be) to the lab bench." I’ve never seen a video so ill-received – a barrage of response videos have appeared on YouTube, and Twitter and Facebook are awash with criticisms, from both official sources, such as Ben Goldacre (author of Bad Science), Nature (the most prestigious science journal), and most of my friends – fiercely intelligent female scientists who I have studied and worked with and learnt from are rightfully angry. As one friend put it “It’s nice to know Marie Curie slowly irradiated herself to death so we could watch a bunch of fashion models play with molecular models while not wearing lab coats.” (Marie Curie was the scientist who discovered radiation, paving the way for a number of important developments including chemotherapy).


The ad is inappropriate on a number of levels. A feminist friend once commented, "advertising is one of our worst enemies." She is correct, but we have the right to expect better from the taxpayer-funded EU Commission. The ad trivialises science and the important work that scientists do; it is insulting to women; and it is far too over-sexualised for something that the EU is aiming at minors (the target audience is 13-18 year old girls).

In advertising, women are by default stick-thin, scantily clad and without depth, intelligence or character. The women in “Science: It’s a Girl Thing!” fit the bill perfectly, but I would have expected better from the EU Commission, which should be trying to tackle negative stereotypes such as these. To make matters worse, the Commission defended the video, saying it wanted to "speak [women’s] language to get their attention." The language of women? The person or persons who devised this ad clearly have a blinding ignorance of science that is second only to their ignorance of women. "When I think woman, I think pink!" We are not simpletons and you cannot interest our entire gender in something by showing us lipstick.

The overtly sexist way in which women are used in advertising is bad enough. But for the EU to stoop to this where the women featured in this video are meant to be representatives of successful female scientists is an attack on women and gender equality, whether meant that way or not.

Science is hard work, and female researchers are intelligent and independent. We have degrees. Many of us have MSc's and the majority of female researchers have doctorates or are working towards them. We work hard to get answers to complicated problems. We mean business and do not spend our days giggling over lipstick and pulling ridiculous faces at chemical formulas, doing catwalk struts around the lab to coquettishly peer over our sunglasses at a male colleague. To take a group of women who have achieved success through their own hard work, on their own merits and their own terms and reduce them into anorexic sex kittens who gasp and giggle over colourful explosions and lipstick is appalling. Maybe it would be funny if gender equality in science were real, but it is not. I can only speak for biomedical science, but women outnumber men at every stage apart from at the most senior levels, which are still male-dominated. The problem is not that we need more women at entry level.

Commenting on the campaign the EU Commissioner for Research, Innovation and Science Máire Geoghegan-Quinn said, “We want to overturn clichés and show women and girls, and boys too, that science is not about old men in white coats".

Admirable sentiments, but to trivialise science with lipstick is extremely insulting to the female scientists – or, as we think of ourselves, “scientists” who do difficult and valuable work every day. I am investigating new ways to treat aggressive breast cancers that do not respond well to drugs. It’s an important project but I accept that it will be relatively thankless. When we are ill we will thank a doctor for prescribing a drug and thank a pharmacist for dispensing it whilst giving little thought to the team of scientists who worked tirelessly to develop and refine it. I’m happy to do it because I want cancer treatments to be better, but I would appreciate it if the EU would not release condescending ad campaigns that could be read as “female scientists only care about cosmetics.” The work we do is very important and this advertisement is positively insulting.

The focus must be on getting the right people into science rather than getting more people into science. I am very proud to be one of several researchers featured in a video made by the Irish Cancer Society late last year. Most of the featured researchers are female, and although we are not strutting our stuff in skimpy dresses and heels that would be positively dangerous in a lab, I think we look pretty good. But far more importantly, we know what we're talking about, care about our research, and we are doing work that is interesting and important. This is the kind of approach that the EU should be taking – showing that it is possible to be respected as a female researcher, and that you have a breadth of opportunities open to you to do interesting and important work, if that’s what you want from life.

If you want to get women into science, make a video about science. Don’t patronise my profession or my gender. Don’t use public money to pay for a video which not only over-sexualises young women, insults female scientists and alienates people to the point where the official video is removed just days after it is posted.

The EU Commission has removed the video, but between the way that women were portrayed, young women were over-sexualised, female scientists were positively ridiculed and public money was wasted on the video, the lack of even a public apology or any sign of abashment from the Commission is perhaps the real political story here.

Naomi Elster holds a 1st class Honours degree in Pharmacology and is currently researching for a PhD at the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, supported by the Irish Cancer Society. She blogs at http://nothingmentionednothinggained.wordpress.com/
10 Comments
http://www.auto-sprzedam.com link
3/9/2014 08:02:22 pm

It is really a nice and useful piece of information. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

Reply
http://www.traveldomain.org link
11/9/2014 02:43:20 pm

Hey there thanks for showing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from personal trainer berlin

Reply
http://www.penthousewilliamsburg.com link
23/9/2014 04:30:27 pm

I like the way you described the topic with such clarity. Thanks for Describing Everything.

Reply
http://www.techhelperusa.com link
10/10/2014 03:33:40 pm

I've just decided to create a blog, which I have been wanting to do for a while. Thanks for this post, it's really useful!

Reply
http://www.hardwarecolombia.com link
23/10/2014 03:09:09 pm

Well, very good post with informative information. I really appreciate the fact that you approach these topics from a stand point of knowledge and information. This is the first time, I visited at your site and became your fan. You are bookmarked. Please keep on posting.

Reply
http://www.pandoraschmuckshop.com link
9/11/2014 05:54:54 pm

I am very happy to discover your post as it will on top in my collection of favorite blogs to visit.

Reply
used-toyota-cars link
18/3/2015 08:50:17 pm

Us Owner of a house Insurance policies – Learn How To Save Close to 20 % Having a Security Established-Up

Reply
youragingpets link
3/4/2015 07:51:51 pm

Hi Krishnan, that’s great! I’ve never cited Tolkein beofre but that fits perfectly in the case of ‘…but some of my best friends are’.

Reply
wafiya link
8/9/2020 06:02:40 am

http://lucknow.wafiya.in
http://chandigarh.wafiya.in
http://jaipur.wafiya.in
http://vadodara.wafiya.in
http://ahmedabad.wafiya.in

Reply
aa
5/10/2020 11:02:03 pm

http://want2relax.biz
http://www.lipkiss.in/agra-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ahmedabad-escorts.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/airhostess-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ambedkar-nagar-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/amritsar-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/andheri-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bandra-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bangalore-escorts-karnataka.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bareilly-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bhuj-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/call-girls-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/belapur-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bhavnagar-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bhopal-escorts-madhya-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/chandigarh-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/chennai-escorts-tamilnadu.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/colaba-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/escorts-in-india.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/escorts-servic-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/faizabad-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/foreigner-escorts-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gandhi-nagar-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gautam-buddha-nagar-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gaya-escorts-bihar.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ghaziabad-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/goa-escorts-goa.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gorakhpur-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gwalior-escorts-madhya-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/haridwar-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/hyderabad-escorts-andhra-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/indian-escorts.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/indore-escorts-madhya-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/jaipur-escorts-rajsthan.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/jalandhar-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/juhu-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/kanpur-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/karjat-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/kerala-escorts-kerala.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/khajuraho-escorts-madhya-pradesh1.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/khar-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/kolkata-escorts-west-bengal.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/lucknow-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ludhiana-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/manali-escorts-himachal-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mathura-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/meerut-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mohali-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/moradabad-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mumbai call girls.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mumbai escorts service.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mumbai-aiport-escorts.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mussoorie-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/muzaffarnagar-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/nainital-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/noida-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/panvel-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/pathankot-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/patna-escorts-bihar.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/pune-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/rajkot-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ranikhet-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/rishikesh-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/russian-escorts-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/saharanpur-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/sakinaka-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/shimla-escorts-himachal-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/surat-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/thane-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/thiruvananthapuram-escorts-kerala html
http://www.lipkiss.in/vadodara-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/vashi-escorts-mumbai.html


http://zanu.in/about.html
http://zanu.in/contact.html
http://zanu.in/gallery.html
http://zanu.in/ahmedabad-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/altamount-road-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/andheri-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/antop-hill-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/ballard-estate-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/bandra-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/belapur-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/bkc-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/borivali-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/breach-candy-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/chembur-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/churchgate-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/colaba-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/cuffe-parade-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/cumbala-hill-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/currey-road-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/dadar-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/fort-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/four-bunglows-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/ghansoli-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/goregaon-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/jogeshwari-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/juhu-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kalamboli-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kamothe-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kandivali-west-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kanjurmarg-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/khar-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kharghar-escorts.html
http

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    We welcome submissions to the blog, subject to editorial review, please contact us if you're interested. The opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the IFN. 

    Categories

    All
    2in2u
    50:50
    Abc
    Abortion
    Abuse
    Action On X
    Advertising
    Austerity
    Backlash
    Bechdel Test
    Body Image
    Bookclub
    Book Club
    Book Review
    Broadcasting Authority Of Ireland
    Budget 2012
    Burlesque
    Caitlin Moran
    Clara Fischer
    Colette Fahy
    Comreg
    Conference
    Cosmetic Surgery
    Cuts
    Dating Violence
    Decision-making
    Democracy
    Diane Kelly
    Domestic Abuse
    Domestic Violence
    Dunnes Stores
    Edinburgh Fringe Festival
    Education
    Emma Regan
    Empowerment
    Equality Audit
    Eu Commission
    Events
    Female Sexual Experience
    Female Sexuality
    Feminism
    Feminism And Gendered Economic Inequality
    Feminism And The University
    Feminism And Young People
    Feminist Activism
    Feminist Books
    F Word
    F-word
    Gaa
    Gender Budgeting
    Gender Equality
    Gender Quotas
    Gender Stereotyping
    Gender-stereotyping
    Ger Walsh
    Government
    GRL
    Guest Blog Post
    Guest Post
    How To Be A Woman
    Hunky Dorys
    Ici
    Ifn
    #IFN2012
    Ifn Conference
    Ifn Events
    Immigrant Council Of Ireland
    Independentwoman.ie
    Ireland
    Irish Examinar
    Irish Feminist Movements
    Irish Feminist Network
    Irish Independent
    Irish Society
    Irish Times
    Iwd
    Jeanette Winterson
    Letters To The Editor
    Lgbt
    Liberation
    Literature
    Marketing
    Maternity Leave
    Media
    Media Images
    Menstruation
    Michelle Mulherin
    Mick Wallace
    Missrepresentation
    Miss Representation
    Music
    Naomi Elster
    News Media
    Nwci
    Objectification
    Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit
    Over Sexualisation
    Padded Bras
    Parental Leave
    Paternity Leave
    Poetry
    Politics
    Posters
    Pre-teens
    Priests For Life
    Privilege Checking
    Pro Choice
    Pro-choice
    Prostitution
    Queer
    Quotas
    Recession
    Reform
    Reproductive Rights
    Ruth Farnan
    Rydyard Kipling
    Science
    Sex
    Sex Education
    Sexism
    Sexism In The Media
    Sexuality
    Sexual Violence
    Silent Majority
    Sisters
    Spunout.ie
    Stripping
    Submissions
    Syria
    Transgender
    Trump
    Turn Off The Red Light
    Tv3
    Twilight
    Under Representation
    United Nations
    Vincent Browne
    Violence
    Weight
    Wexford
    Whai
    Women
    Women Hurt
    Women In Science
    Women In Sport
    Women In Syria
    Women's Aid
    Women’s History Association Of Ireland
    Workshop
    X Case

    Archives

    July 2017
    November 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    May 2011

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission Statement
    • Our Work
    • The Coordinators
  • Publications
  • News & Events
  • Articles
  • Take Action
  • Contact Us
    • Irish Organisations