![]() I was recently misfortunate enough to spend some time as an inpatient in hospital. While I was there, I was captive audience for RTÉ, who to my horror still give two days of prime time TV coverage to the over-hyped, insipid beauty pageant that is the Rose of Tralee. My reasons for disliking the Rose of Tralee are far from original. It’s a beauty contest, sexist nonsense, nothing more to it than the “lovely girls competition” that was parodied excellently on Father Ted. The girls get dressed up, laugh prettily at the male host’s witless jokes, and recite a poem about how much they love their homeland before, demure and docile, they waltz off the stage. The Rose of Tralee website, of course, oversells the event, claiming that “A Rose reflects the intelligence, compassion and independence of modern Irish women,” and “represents the collective aspirations, social responsibilities and ambitions of young women.” To any woman who is intelligent, independent, compassionate and has meaningful aspirations, this is downright insulting and condescending. If any of the “Roses” were endowed with wonderful, inspiring qualities, they were given no chance to display them. They stood on stage while the male host delivered tired “look at all these lovely girls” clichés, and simpered while they patiently waited to get a word in edgeways. The competition would be a lot less condescending if it would drop the pretence at being anything other than a twee, outdated fashion show. There’s no intelligence or independence to that spectacle, and certainly no relevance to “the modern Irish woman.” If the emphasis is on personality, why must you be under 28 to enter? Why are you ineligible if you are or ever have been married? So that “good Catholic Irish men” can daydream (or masturbate) over you without feeling guilty?
And then there are the “Rose Buds.” These are children, aged 6-12, who are paired up with a Rose and go “on tour” with them in exchange for participating in parades and a free JLS ticket. Some of the Roses spoke of how the “Rose Buds” were “a great help” and the “cute factor” is an almost guaranteed positive PR spin for the event. Please tell me how this is not exploitation, and how there is anything positive or progressive about training children to grow up to be beauty queens. Beauty pageants objectify women and I don’t think a convincing argument can be made otherwise. They are about women seeking approval, male approval for the most part, based on their looks. The worrying thing about modern beauty pageants is that this approval-seeking may now be subconscious. It’s heart-breaking to look at all the Roses and wonder who they are really, as people, and ask if this is what they derive their sense of self-worth from, and disturbing to think of children getting caught up in that situation. From a misrepresentation of women point of view, there is so much that is wrong or embarrassing about the Rose of Tralee. But much as I would love to see it gone, it is problematic to suggest it should be banned – what next? No blond-haired people in positions of power? You get the idea. But I do think that the extent to which RTÉ covers the event needs to be looked at. Contrast the two-day, prime-time coverage of this beauty pageant with the sparsity of airtime given to women’s sports compared to men’s sports on the same station, and the way female Olympic athletes last year were consistently referred to as “girls.” During the women’s sailing event, the competitors weren’t deemed worthy of names by the male commentators: “the Dutch girl” ,“the American girl.” We pay a licence fee to RTÉ. From next year we will be paying a licence fee even if we don’t own a television set. We already get appallingly bad value for our fee. In the UK, people pay a licence to the BBC. In exchange, BBC commissions new shows, from good old-fashioned soap operas to educational documentaries and probing current affairs programmes, and BBC audiences are also not subjected to advertising. In the USA, advertising was sold by television stations as an alternative to charging viewers a licence fee. Here in Ireland, we pay both, and what do we get in return? Repeats of shows commissioned and made elsewhere, for the most part. And of course we get the Rose of Tralee, which is as much a staple of the RTÉ schedule as the Angelus prayer, and probably appeals to the same defunct market. For a publically-funded television station which already delivers very poor value to the Irish public to endorse and institutionalise this objectification and sexism is not acceptable in this day and age. Some have attempted to justify this coverage, claiming that the “festival” is a tourist attraction. Excepting the Roses’ friends and families, who will come regardless of the national coverage it gets, do you know anyone who ever came to Ireland and spent money here because of the Rose of Tralee? Funny, me neither. - Naomi Elster is a scientist and a writer. She is currently researching more effective ways to treat breast cancer at the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, supported by the Irish Cancer Society. She is deputy editor of HeadSpace, a non-profit mental health magazine distributed for free to service users of psychiatric wards and mental health support centres. Her play "Scabs" ran as part of this year's 10 days in Dublin festival. She blogs at http://nothingmentionednothinggained.wordpress.com.
25 Comments
Michele McCormack
30/5/2014 02:28:24 am
If the Rose of Tralee were a beauty pageant then the prettiest woman would win. That never happens.
Reply
27/8/2014 03:28:55 pm
I like this post. It's quite unusual and innovative. Writer might be really gorgeous. Someone could easily claim that he is a genius.
Reply
9/9/2014 07:20:56 pm
I am gonna bookmark this page, thanks for info. I actually appreciate your own position and I will be sure to come back here.
Reply
21/9/2014 07:25:10 pm
Thanks for the information! Now I know what i will do the next time i travel. Looking forward to go to Thailand later this year! Thanks for some pointers!
Reply
29/9/2014 05:38:39 pm
Dear, I am very like your website and all post. it is great and usefull for us. i will often come here,and support any post which your push. Tks.
Reply
19/10/2014 04:37:14 pm
You might write about the services on the blog. You should disclose it's refreshing. Your blog conclusion could accelerate your shoppers.
Reply
7/11/2014 01:23:05 pm
I am really glad to be here.I hope to see more great articles here in the future too so keep it up and good luck to all of you!
Reply
11/3/2015 03:43:40 pm
I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand.
Reply
25/3/2015 02:21:46 pm
This is truly good content and informative weblog, I praise what youve done here, along with sharing great material with excellent suggestions and concepts, Im truly pleased to post my comment on this weblog, many thank yous to the author.
Reply
1/4/2015 07:59:24 pm
I am interested in this topic and would like to find out some more information as my friend need information on this topic. Do you have any other articles about this
Reply
26/8/2015 05:56:04 pm
A thousand thanks, the paper is truly advantageous! It is clear that the author is a proficient in this specialty area. Contrast to all those materials I have already read on the issue, this one has fresh solutions. The web site regularly procures plenty readable works on the vital subjects. My mother and I skim them several times a day.
Reply
10/9/2015 04:59:52 am
Reply
15/9/2015 01:59:20 am
Great post! Thnaks for great job! I will ad in bookmarks! Good luck!
Reply
22/11/2015 12:29:25 pm
Single folks who aren't instructed can't arrive a not all that terrible position to support their youths, which is a need in their circumstances. Being educated can offer a solitary parent some help with discovering occupations furthermore make them aware of particular arrangements.
Reply
7/9/2016 07:33:00 am
Here the homepage for free amazon gift card code generator online.
Reply
11/3/2017 10:38:05 pm
nice post. Pic is good. thanks for sharing.
Reply
Thank you so much for the great and very beneficial stuff that you have shared with the world. You may already have changed lots and lots of people’s life just from your experience and skills. In fact, I wanted to start my own blog to raise awareness of family breakups and the loss of many children who got involved with the gang and drugs dealing. I want to teach, support and empower the young couples and parents in order to prevent them from family failures and breakups.
Reply
Very helpful articlel. I am looking for an alternative to WordPress, which I detest. I have used it for many years, and it is time for change. I have used Blogger, which I like, and monetise effectively. However, the lack of support and times off line is of concern. However, I will now try one of your other suggestions. By the way, I used Bluehost for many years, but their excellent customer support rapidly deteriorated a couple of years ago – I think the company changed hands. Been with Inmotion ever since, and I cannot fault them. Thanks for your tips.
Reply
http://ansu.co.in
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
We welcome submissions to the blog, subject to editorial review, please contact us if you're interested. The opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the IFN.
Categories
All
Archives
July 2017
|