Irish Feminist Network
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission Statement
    • Our Work
    • The Coordinators
  • Publications
  • News & Events
  • Articles
  • Take Action
  • Contact Us
    • Irish Organisations

Twenty years after the X case, it’s time for action on abortion

7/2/2012

8 Comments

 
Cross posting this article written by Alison Spillane from TheJournal.ie.


Twenty years on from the landmark Supreme Court ruling in the X case it is both astonishing and disheartening that so little progress has been made.

Over the past two decades, successive governments have failed to legislate for the Supreme Court judgment which established the right of women to access abortion when their lives are at risk, including the risk of suicide. In so doing, they have withheld a constitutional right from women in Ireland.

In the interim, we have seen a working group, a Cabinet committee, an Oireachtas committee and two referenda (1992 and 2002) in which the Irish people reaffirmed the Supreme Court ruling by refusing to remove suicide as legitimate grounds for abortion. More recently, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled in ABC v Ireland that the rights of Applicant C had been violated under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights due to the State’s failure to legislate for the existing constitutional right to abortion. The Court noted there was a “striking discordance” between the theoretical right to a lawful abortion in Ireland on grounds of a relevant risk to a woman’s life and the reality of its practical implementation.

In January this year, after much can-kicking, Minister for Health James Reilly appointed a 14-member expert group to consider the ECHR  judgment of December 2010. The expert group is charged with examining the options available to the government on how to implement this ruling.

In one sense, the establishment of the expert group is a step in the right direction but it is also a delaying tactic allowing government to push this issue to the margins for as long as possible. The reality is that an expert group is not necessary – the legislation required for X is in fact relatively straightforward (although we must be careful the law is not too rigid); the element requiring the most work is the medical guidelines needed to accompany it which should provide long overdue clarity for medical professionals who have been forced to censor themselves due to the severe penalties they could receive under archaic legislation.

Do we really need to legislate for X?

Often when the X Case comes up in the public domain the argument thrown up by the pro-life lobby is that, as things stand, doctors will always act to save the life of a woman even if this means unintentionally terminating her pregnancy, thus there is no need for legislation in this regard.

In reality, things are far more complex than that. As demonstrated by the ABC case where Applicant C – a woman in remission from cancer – found she could not access clear medical advice about the threat to her life if she continued with the pregnancy, or the damage that may have been done to the foetus as a results of tests she had undergone as part of her cancer treatment. Doctors stayed silent, left in a very unclear situation themselves, and were unwilling to advise this woman because of the legal implications surrounding abortion provision. Due to the negative climate around abortion in Ireland doctors are fearful and often unsure whether they can assist a woman, for example, in the provision of post-abortion care – abortion remains a criminal offence under 1861 legislation, carrying a maximum penalty of life imprisonment.

As a result of the failure to legislate for X, Sections 58 and 59 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 are still in force meaning that women and medical professionals run a risk of serious criminal conviction. As the European Court of Human Rights observed, “The criminal provisions of the 1861 Act would constitute a significant chilling factor for both women and doctors in the medical consultation process, regardless of whether or not prosecutions have in fact been pursued under that Act”.

Why has the State not acted?

As part of its defence in the ABC case, the Irish government argued that restrictions on abortion in Ireland were based on “profound moral values deeply embedded in the fabric of society”. Recent opinion polls, however, beg to differ. The inaugural Irish Times/Behaviour & Attitudes Social Poll published in October 2007 found that 69% of women believe the government should legislate for abortion where the woman’s life is at risk. In 2010 a Marie Stopes/YouGov poll found that 87% of those questioned supported abortion where a pregnancy seriously endangers a woman’s life. It is clear that Irish attitudes to abortion have liberalised significantly over the past two decades.


Successive governments have displayed extreme political cowardice and conservatism in their refusal to introduce the relevant legislation. For the most part elected representatives have been afraid to touch the topic and in doing so they have greatly underestimated the electorate, as demonstrated by the opinion polls above. To be fair to backbench and opposition TDs, the pro-life lobby has traditionally been more visible and vocal on this issue (due in part to the rather staggering amount of resources it seems to have at its disposal) and elected representatives need to know that their constituents support them before they take a stand.


Unfortunately, this issue has for too long been monopolised by an extremely vocal and well-resourced minority who cry “Murder!” at the slightest mention of women’s reproductive rights. This approach stifles public debate and hinders reasonable discussion about a very complex topic. In advocating the right of women to access abortion when their lives are at risk, including the threat of suicide, I do not expect everyone to agree with me. But it is unjust for those who disagree to force that opinion on the rest of us, thereby preventing women from accessing life-saving treatment and doctors from providing proper and necessary care to patients. For twenty years this has been the status quo in Ireland, and the time to act is long overdue.

Alison Spillane is a political researcher and a co-ordinator of the Irish Feminist Network.

8 Comments
http://www.autoclima-u-go.com link
3/9/2014 08:12:11 pm

A good informative post that you have shared and appreciate your work for sharing the information.

Reply
http://www.emmrautoauction.org link
11/9/2014 04:44:59 pm

Excellent share, this is a really quality post. In underlying objects theory I’d like to write like this too. Taking time and real effort to make a good article.

Reply
http://www.eldercarematterscanada.com link
23/9/2014 05:23:53 pm

It was a positive conversation and each day since then he has made an effort to come and speak to her about his success of the day. 

Reply
http://www.renoracepromotion.com link
11/11/2014 03:10:48 pm

Hey there thanks for showing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from personal trainer berlin

Reply
newfairfieldhealth link
19/3/2015 04:13:56 pm

So ncie good psot s cinegreat!

Reply
missautohof link
7/4/2015 02:33:18 pm

You may post on the professional credentials for the blog owner. You could express it's outstanding. Your blog experience can springboard your click through.

Reply
missautohof link
7/4/2015 02:33:28 pm

You may post on the professional credentials for the blog owner. You could express it's outstanding. Your blog experience can springboard your click through.

Reply
aa
5/10/2020 10:54:44 pm

http://want2relax.biz
http://www.lipkiss.in/agra-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ahmedabad-escorts.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/airhostess-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ambedkar-nagar-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/amritsar-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/andheri-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bandra-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bangalore-escorts-karnataka.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bareilly-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bhuj-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/call-girls-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/belapur-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bhavnagar-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/bhopal-escorts-madhya-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/chandigarh-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/chennai-escorts-tamilnadu.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/colaba-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/escorts-in-india.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/escorts-servic-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/faizabad-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/foreigner-escorts-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gandhi-nagar-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gautam-buddha-nagar-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gaya-escorts-bihar.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ghaziabad-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/goa-escorts-goa.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gorakhpur-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/gwalior-escorts-madhya-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/haridwar-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/hyderabad-escorts-andhra-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/indian-escorts.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/indore-escorts-madhya-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/jaipur-escorts-rajsthan.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/jalandhar-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/juhu-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/kanpur-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/karjat-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/kerala-escorts-kerala.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/khajuraho-escorts-madhya-pradesh1.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/khar-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/kolkata-escorts-west-bengal.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/lucknow-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ludhiana-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/manali-escorts-himachal-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mathura-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/meerut-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mohali-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/moradabad-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mumbai call girls.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mumbai escorts service.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mumbai-aiport-escorts.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/mussoorie-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/muzaffarnagar-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/nainital-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/noida-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/panvel-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/pathankot-escorts-punjab.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/patna-escorts-bihar.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/pune-escorts-maharashtra.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/rajkot-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/ranikhet-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/rishikesh-escorts-uttarakhand.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/russian-escorts-in-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/saharanpur-escorts-uttar-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/sakinaka-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/shimla-escorts-himachal-pradesh.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/surat-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/thane-escorts-mumbai.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/thiruvananthapuram-escorts-kerala html
http://www.lipkiss.in/vadodara-escorts-gujarat.html
http://www.lipkiss.in/vashi-escorts-mumbai.html


http://zanu.in/about.html
http://zanu.in/contact.html
http://zanu.in/gallery.html
http://zanu.in/ahmedabad-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/altamount-road-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/andheri-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/antop-hill-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/ballard-estate-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/bandra-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/belapur-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/bkc-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/borivali-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/breach-candy-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/chembur-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/churchgate-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/colaba-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/cuffe-parade-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/cumbala-hill-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/currey-road-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/dadar-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/fort-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/four-bunglows-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/ghansoli-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/goregaon-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/jogeshwari-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/juhu-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kalamboli-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kamothe-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kandivali-west-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kanjurmarg-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/khar-escorts.html
http://zanu.in/kharghar-escorts.html
http

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    We welcome submissions to the blog, subject to editorial review, please contact us if you're interested. The opinions expressed here do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the IFN. 

    Categories

    All
    2in2u
    50:50
    Abc
    Abortion
    Abuse
    Action On X
    Advertising
    Austerity
    Backlash
    Bechdel Test
    Body Image
    Bookclub
    Book Club
    Book Review
    Broadcasting Authority Of Ireland
    Budget 2012
    Burlesque
    Caitlin Moran
    Clara Fischer
    Colette Fahy
    Comreg
    Conference
    Cosmetic Surgery
    Cuts
    Dating Violence
    Decision-making
    Democracy
    Diane Kelly
    Domestic Abuse
    Domestic Violence
    Dunnes Stores
    Edinburgh Fringe Festival
    Education
    Emma Regan
    Empowerment
    Equality Audit
    Eu Commission
    Events
    Female Sexual Experience
    Female Sexuality
    Feminism
    Feminism And Gendered Economic Inequality
    Feminism And The University
    Feminism And Young People
    Feminist Activism
    Feminist Books
    F Word
    F-word
    Gaa
    Gender Budgeting
    Gender Equality
    Gender Quotas
    Gender Stereotyping
    Gender-stereotyping
    Ger Walsh
    Government
    GRL
    Guest Blog Post
    Guest Post
    How To Be A Woman
    Hunky Dorys
    Ici
    Ifn
    #IFN2012
    Ifn Conference
    Ifn Events
    Immigrant Council Of Ireland
    Independentwoman.ie
    Ireland
    Irish Examinar
    Irish Feminist Movements
    Irish Feminist Network
    Irish Independent
    Irish Society
    Irish Times
    Iwd
    Jeanette Winterson
    Letters To The Editor
    Lgbt
    Liberation
    Literature
    Marketing
    Maternity Leave
    Media
    Media Images
    Menstruation
    Michelle Mulherin
    Mick Wallace
    Missrepresentation
    Miss Representation
    Music
    Naomi Elster
    News Media
    Nwci
    Objectification
    Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit
    Over Sexualisation
    Padded Bras
    Parental Leave
    Paternity Leave
    Poetry
    Politics
    Posters
    Pre-teens
    Priests For Life
    Privilege Checking
    Pro Choice
    Pro-choice
    Prostitution
    Queer
    Quotas
    Recession
    Reform
    Reproductive Rights
    Ruth Farnan
    Rydyard Kipling
    Science
    Sex
    Sex Education
    Sexism
    Sexism In The Media
    Sexuality
    Sexual Violence
    Silent Majority
    Sisters
    Spunout.ie
    Stripping
    Submissions
    Syria
    Transgender
    Trump
    Turn Off The Red Light
    Tv3
    Twilight
    Under Representation
    United Nations
    Vincent Browne
    Violence
    Weight
    Wexford
    Whai
    Women
    Women Hurt
    Women In Science
    Women In Sport
    Women In Syria
    Women's Aid
    Women’s History Association Of Ireland
    Workshop
    X Case

    Archives

    July 2017
    November 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    May 2011

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About
    • Mission Statement
    • Our Work
    • The Coordinators
  • Publications
  • News & Events
  • Articles
  • Take Action
  • Contact Us
    • Irish Organisations